Kimmel eventually made it to the merge, and on Still and amanda ozzy Are dating kimmel 30, and became the 12th person voted out and the fourth member of the jury, finishing in ninth place. In the end Kimmel finished third, behind winner Herzog and second-place finisher Yates, garnering only one jury vote from sixth-place finisher Erik Huffmann. The pageant was won by Chelsea Cooley of North Carolina. Cook Still and amanda ozzy Are dating kimmel. This group now also includes: Upon getting voted out, Kimmel had spent a cumulative days on the show, which extended her own record. ThomasCandice Woodcock, Rupert Boneham and Donaldson securing her to win the season by a 6—3—0 margin. As Mikumi in Oral sex the reunion show, they were still dating, but they subsequently separated. Villains, Jeff Probst announced on the season's 22nd day that Kimmel was the first contestant to spend a cumulative days competing on Survivor. Pageantry[ edit ] Kimmel won the Miss Montana USA title after placing first runner-up in both the and pageants. Kimmel was selected to represent the United States in this pageant from a group of applicants, and did not compete in a live competition for the title.